brainy/docs/guides/storage-adapters.md
David Snelling 9f9a41599e chore(8.0): step-7 follow-through — collapse remaining cloud branches + docs sweep (scaffold step 13)
Final cleanup pass for Brainy 8.0. Catches three categories of debt:

A. STEP-7 FOLLOW-THROUGH (rebuild-path collapse)

Step 7's bisect-reset (debugging a flaky test) lost the in-source edits
to three rebuild paths even though the commit message claimed they
shipped. Re-applied now:

- src/utils/metadataIndex.ts — collapsed the `isLocalStorage` /
  cloud-pagination branching. Local-load-all-at-once is the only path
  in 8.0. Removed ~150 LOC of paginated-cloud branching for both nouns
  and verbs, plus the safety counters (`consecutiveEmptyBatches`,
  `MAX_ITERATIONS`, etc.).
- src/hnsw/hnswIndex.ts — same simplification for HNSW rebuild. The
  paginated cloud path is gone; HNSW now loads all nodes at once.
  Removed ~85 LOC.
- src/graph/graphAdjacencyIndex.ts — same simplification for graph
  adjacency rebuild. Removed ~50 LOC.

The collapse is safe because cloud adapters were deleted in step 7;
`storageType === 'OPFSStorage'` (and similar) can never match now.

B. CLOUD-ONLY DOCS DELETED

- docs/operations/cost-optimization-aws-s3.md
- docs/operations/cost-optimization-azure.md
- docs/operations/cost-optimization-cloudflare-r2.md
- docs/operations/cost-optimization-gcs.md
- docs/operations/cloud-run-filestore-guide.md

(docs/deployment/* contained no cloud-specific files that needed deletion.)

C. STORAGE-ADAPTERS GUIDE REWRITTEN FOR 8.0

docs/guides/storage-adapters.md → fresh content reflecting the 8.0
reality:
- Two adapters: FileSystemStorage + MemoryStorage. Quick-start matrix.
- Cloud backup section explains the operator-tooling pattern (gsutil /
  aws s3 / rclone / azcopy) with the exact commands consumers will run.
- "Why no cloud adapters in 8.0?" section documents the four reasons
  per BR-BRAINY-80-STORAGE-SIMPLIFY.
- Migration recipe for 7.x cloud-adapter consumers: mount local disk →
  filesystem storage → operator backup cron.

Updated frontmatter description so soulcraft.com/docs renders the
correct preview.

NOT IN THIS COMMIT (deliberate, lower-priority)

- src/storage/cacheManager.ts still references StorageType.S3 /
  REMOTE_API / OPFS as dead branches (23 sites). The branches are never
  reached in 8.0, but cleaning them would cascade through 5 consumers.
  Defer to a follow-up if the dead code surfaces as a real maintenance
  issue.
- src/config/storageAutoConfig.ts keeps its StorageType enum + autodetect
  for 7.x compat surface. Same reason: rewriting cascades through
  zeroConfig, extensibleConfig, sharedConfigManager. Defer.
- docs/MIGRATION-V3-TO-V4.md and docs/DEVELOPER_LEARNING_PATH.md still
  reference cloud adapters as historical artefacts. That's accurate —
  they describe how things used to be. Left as-is.
- @deprecated audit in src/ (10 files) deferred — audit each individually
  in a future polish pass.

VERIFICATION

- npx tsc --noEmit: clean
- npm test: 1408 / 1409 (same pre-existing race-condition outstanding from
  step 7; no regressions from this cleanup)
2026-06-09 15:05:02 -07:00

5.1 KiB

title slug public category template order description next
Storage Adapters guides/storage-adapters true guides guide 2 Two adapters cover every deployment: in-memory for tests + ephemeral workloads, filesystem for everything that needs to persist. Both support copy-on-write branching. Cloud backup is operator tooling, not a built-in adapter.
guides/plugins
concepts/zero-config

Storage Adapters

Brainy 8.0 ships two storage adapters:

  • FileSystemStorage — persistent on-disk storage. The default for any deployment that needs to survive a restart. Runs on Node.js, Bun, and Deno.
  • MemoryStorage — in-memory only. The right choice for tests, ephemeral workloads, and short-lived demos.

Both implement the same StorageAdapter interface, support copy-on-write branching, and use the same on-disk layout (memory's "disk" is a JS Map).

Quick start

import { Brainy } from '@soulcraft/brainy'

// Filesystem (recommended for any persistent workload):
const brain = new Brainy({
  storage: { type: 'filesystem', rootDirectory: './brainy-data' }
})

// Memory (tests, ephemeral):
const brainMem = new Brainy({ storage: { type: 'memory' } })

// Auto-detect (filesystem on Node-like runtimes, memory in browsers):
const brainAuto = new Brainy({ storage: { type: 'auto' } })

When to use which

Use case Adapter Why
Production app filesystem Durable, branchable, mmap-able
Tests, CI memory No disk teardown; fast
Short-lived data pipeline memory No persistence needed
In-browser demo memory Filesystem unavailable in browsers
Cloud deployment filesystem on local disk + operator backup See "Cloud backup" below

Cloud backup — operator tooling, not a built-in

Brainy 8.0 deliberately ships no cloud storage adapters. Cloud backup is handled at the operator layer with standard tooling, the same pattern every production database uses (Postgres, SQLite, Redis):

# After a brainy flush, sync the on-disk artefact to your cloud of choice.
gsutil rsync -r /var/lib/brainy gs://my-backup-bucket/brainy/
# or:
aws s3 sync /var/lib/brainy s3://my-backup-bucket/brainy/
# or:
rclone sync /var/lib/brainy remote:brainy-backups/
# or:
azcopy sync /var/lib/brainy "https://account.blob.core.windows.net/brainy?sv=..."

Brainy's filesystem layout is sync-friendly:

  • Atomic writes (temp + rename) — readers never see torn files
  • Per-shard files — rsync-style incremental sync works well
  • Content-addressed blobs (_blobs/) — immutable, cache-friendly
  • Branch refs live under _cow/ — pick up branches automatically

For point-in-time backups, take a filesystem snapshot (ZFS, btrfs, LVM, EBS, etc.) or use brain.persist(path) to write a self-contained snapshot you can sync independently of the live brain.

Why no cloud adapters in 8.0?

Cloud storage adapters lived in Brainy 4.x-7.x. They were dropped in 8.0 per BR-BRAINY-80-STORAGE-SIMPLIFY because:

  • Zero production consumers used them at scale. Every Soulcraft consumer ran on local filesystem.
  • Cloud-storage HNSW / DiskANN doesn't perform — vector indexes need low-latency random reads that S3 / GCS / R2 / Azure can't provide consistently.
  • Bundling cloud SDKs into the library cost ~3000-5000 LOC + 4-7 transitive dependencies for a feature nobody used.
  • Cloud backup via operator tooling is strictly more reliable than in-app upload (better retry semantics, better observability, better cost control).

Brainy 8.0 is smaller, faster to install, and clearer about what it does.

Configuration

interface StorageOptions {
  // The adapter type. Defaults to 'auto'.
  type?: 'auto' | 'memory' | 'filesystem'

  // Force a specific adapter regardless of type.
  forceMemoryStorage?: boolean
  forceFileSystemStorage?: boolean

  // Filesystem only.
  rootDirectory?: string

  // COW branch to open. Defaults to 'main'.
  branch?: string

  // COW compression toggle. Defaults to true.
  enableCompression?: boolean
}

Direct construction

If you want to skip the factory:

import { FileSystemStorage, MemoryStorage } from '@soulcraft/brainy'

const fsStorage = new FileSystemStorage('./brainy-data')
const memStorage = new MemoryStorage()

const brain = new Brainy({ storage: fsStorage })

Migration from 7.x cloud adapters

7.x consumers of OPFSStorage, GcsStorage, R2Storage, S3CompatibleStorage, or AzureBlobStorage need to migrate to FileSystemStorage plus operator backup tooling. The recipe:

  1. On the host running Brainy, mount a local disk (NVMe recommended). Cloud providers all expose persistent local disks: GCP Persistent Disk, AWS EBS, Azure Managed Disks.
  2. Set storage: { type: 'filesystem', rootDirectory: '/mnt/brainy-data' }.
  3. Run your existing data import once into the new local store.
  4. Set up an operator backup job using gsutil / aws s3 / rclone / azcopy on a cron — hourly or whatever your RPO requires. Point it at the brainy data dir.
  5. For point-in-time backups, use filesystem snapshots or brain.persist().

Same data, same APIs, no library-side cloud code.